[Talk-at] [mechanical édit] change depreciated tag wood=* by leaf_cycle=*/leaf_type=*

Robert Kaiser kairo at kairo.at
Fri Sep 23 20:27:11 UTC 2022


Marc_marc via Talk-at schrieb:
> I propose to make a  a mechanical édit (=edit without human review of 
> individual objets) in Austria to replace the deprecated wood=* tag
>
> the doc of the tag https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Key%3Awood
>
> there are currently 323 objects and 3 values of which here are
> the conversions:
> wood=coniferous -> leaf_type=needleleaved
> wood=deciduous -> leaf_cycle=deciduous
> wood=mixed -> leaf_type=mixed
>
> For objects that already have the new tag, the old tag is simply deleted
>
> In case of conflict (old and new tag giving different information),
> the object is not modified by the mechanical edit (it could
> be treated by hand, currently no conflict remain)
>
> it will be done with the usual changeset tag for this kind
> of operation and the wiki page according to the automated editing 
> guidelines.
>
> opinion ?

To me, those changes sound good, contrary to Friedrich, I also do not 
see anything that gets lost, but we do get the information moved to the 
more consistent schemes, which makes sense.

KaiRo




More information about the Talk-at mailing list